The Ontario government accepts the need for change to the involuntary detention procedures of the Mental Health Act

March 6, 2015

Share Post

*Content posted to the blog represents the views of the author only and not those of Health Law in Canada, its Board members or affiliates or IHPME*

Stethoscope inside a glass circle with blue backgroundThe case of P.S. v Ontario, 2014 ONCA 900 was a landmark decision by Justice Sharpe where the Constitutional validity of involuntary detention provisions under the Ontario Mental Health Act (MHA) were challenged.

P.S. was sentenced to 45 months imprisonment for the sexual assault of a minor. After the completion of his sentence, he was deemed by the Consent and Capacity Board to be a risk to society and thus transferred to the Waypoint Centre’s maximum security facility. Most of these involuntary detentions last less than one month, but P.S. has been held at this facility for over 19 years. A two-word loophole in section 20(4)(b)(iii) of the MHA provides the authority for such long-term detainment;

“An involuntary patient may be detained, restrained, observed and examined in a psychiatric facility… (b) for not more than… (iii) three additional months under a third or subsequent certificate of renewal, that is completed and filed with the officer in charge by the attending physician [emphasis added].”

This provision led Justice Sharpe to declare that P.S.’s section 7 right to liberty under the Canadian Charter had been infringed and that there should be a six-month limit on detentions, especially considering that the MHA does not possess sufficient procedural powers to ensure that individuals detained for longer periods of time will be appropriately cared for. The Consent and Capacity Board, composed largely of mental health professionals, repeatedly recommended that P.S. be transferred to a lower security facility more appropriate for the treatment of his condition. However, because the Board did not have the authority to demand his transfer and the other facilities would not accept him, he remains in the maximum security section of the Waypoint Centre.

Justice Sharpe also declared P.S.’s rights under s.15 of the Charter, the right not to be discriminated against, was infringed. P.S. is deaf and was not provided the appropriate communicative assistance required to treat his condition. As Justice Sharpe stated, “[h]ad efforts been made to accommodate him immediately following his committal in 1996 by providing interpretation services during therapeutic, educational and recreational programming, his well-being and overall rehabilitative prospects might have been markedly different.”

Due to these breaches, the court declared that the words “or subsequent” in s20(4)(b)(iii) of the MHA are of no force or effect. However, they’ve suspended this declaration of invalidity for 12 months in order to allow the legislature time to appropriately amend the provision. Since the deadline to appeal this decision passed last week with no word from the provincial government, it is likely that Justice Sharpe’s ruling will be implemented.

As of February 28th, the Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care is reviewing the options available to respond to the court’s decision and plan their next steps.

Leane Lardner
Managing Editor – Communications

Related News

Black and white photograph of two individuals. The person on the left is wearing a blazer over a dark shirt, and the person on the right has long wavy hair and is wearing a light-colored top. The background is blue with abstract shapes in purple, green, orange, and blue at the corners.

Empowering Future Leaders in Health: Meet the 2025–26 C. David Naylor Fellows

June 9, 2025

Students

Read More
A collage of five headshots, the 2025–26 Vector Scholars, arranged in a 3x3 grid, with alternating colored squares in blue, dark blue, light blue, purple, green, and yellow filling the empty spaces; the individuals have varied hairstyles and clothing.

Advancing the Future of Health Through AI: IHPME Students Recognized with 2025–26 Vector Scholarships

May 29, 2025

Awards / Students

Read More
A digitally altered photo of three people standing side by side with faces obscured by gray rectangles; the background is a blurred, blue-tinted urban scene with colorful bars in orange, green, and purple in the corners.

IHPME-Affiliated Team Looped Advances in AI Competition

May 27, 2025

Faculty / Research / Students

Read More
A collage of images from the 21st Annual Research and Impact Day. The images include various scenes such as people receiving awards, attendees engaging in discussions, a keynote speaker presenting, and a display table with informational materials.

Bridging Research and Reality: 21st Annual Research and Impact Day Highlights Innovation and Collaboration

May 12, 2025

Faculty / Research / Students

Read More
A group of people are posing for a photo in a classroom. They are standing and kneeling in front of a large white projection screen. The room has wooden paneling on the walls and several desks with chairs arranged in rows. Some individuals are wearing masks, and various casual outfits can be seen.

Innovation in Action: Highlights from the 6th Health Systems AI Hackathon

April 30, 2025

Faculty / Research / Students

Read More
Portrait of Dr. Andrew Boozary, man with dark curly hair wearing a stethoscope around his neck and a black blazer with a red pin. He is standing in front of a whiteboard with pink writing."

Integrating Housing and Health: Dr. Andrew Boozary’s Vision for a More Equitable Toronto

April 25, 2025

Faculty

Read More

Sign up for IHPME Connect.

Keep up to date with IHPME’s News & Research, Events & Program, Recognition, e-newsletter.

Subscribe to Connect Newsletter

Get in Contact


Communications

Marielle Boutin
Email Address: ihpme.communications@​utoronto.ca

Manages all IHPME-wide communications and marketing initiatives, including events and announcements.