A Brief History of Regulating Assisted Human Reproduction in Canada

January 29, 2019

Share Post

by  Maria Aurora Nunez

*Content posted to the blog represents the views of the author only and not those of Health Law in Canada, its Board members or affiliates or IHPME*

In 2018, Stephen Hawking predicted that “we are now entering a new phase of what might be called self-designed evolution”.[1] Genetic editing, starting with the repair of genetic defects, may eventually result in a race of Painting of a child seated with a flower in her hair“superhumans” against which the non-genetically-edited, “unimproved humans […] won’t be able to compete”.[2] While superhumans may be science-fiction, genetic editing of human embryos is already a new reality.[3] Technology, comprising of assisted reproductive technology (ART), is advancing at a rapid speed, faster than advancements in the regulation of ART in Canada.

The world’s first baby conceived by in vitro fertilization (IVF), a type of ART, was born in England in 1978.[4] The first baby conceived by IVF in Canada was born in British Columbia in 1983.[5] At that time, ART was unregulated in Canada. In 1989, in response to increasing public demand, the federal government established the Royal Commission on New Reproductive Technologies to study the social, ethical, legal, health and economic implications of ART. In 1993—after four years, $28 million dollars and consultations with roughly 40,000 Canadians—the Royal Commission issued its final report Proceed with Care. The report contained 293 recommendations on what policies and safeguards Canada should adopt to balance the benefits of ART with its issues, including dangerous and discriminatory practices. The report concluded that there was an urgent need for federal legislation to limit the use of ART and a body to oversee, licence and monitor the use of ART: “The field is developing too rapidly, and the potential for harm to citizens is too great, for Canada’s response to be delayed, fragmented, or tentative”.[6] In 1995, the Minister of Health called for a voluntary moratorium on nine practices, such as sex selection for non-medical reasons, commercial surrogacy arrangements and retrieval of eggs from cadavers or fetuses. However, most IVF clinics did not adhere to the moratorium.[7] In 1996, Bill C-47, the Human Reproductive and Genetic Technologies Act was introduced; however, it died in 1997 when a federal election was called.[8][9]germline genetic alteration[10][11] Whereas almost 30 years ago Canada welcomed its first IVF-baby, today it is estimated that over 8 million babies have been born from IVF worldwide.[12] However, regulation of ART in Canada remains fragmented.

Health Canada intends to strengthen the AHRA by bringing into force dormant sections and developing regulations for the: (i) use of donor gametes, (ii) reimbursement of expenses incurred by donors and surrogates and (iii) administration and enforcement. The public has been provided an opportunity to give feedback on the proposed AHRA changes. On January 10, 2019, public consultation closed. [13]  Bringing sections of the AHRA into force could help to provide clarity for Canadians on the use of ART services and better protect the health and safety of Canadians. We will have to wait to see what happens to the regulation of ART in Canada, tomorrow and onward.

[1] See e.g. Health Canada, Consultation on proposed assisted human reproduction regulations (Ottawa, Health Canada), online:<https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/programs/consultation-assisted-human-reproduction-regulations.html> (Date modified: 30 November 2018).

[4] “The world’s first test tube baby: reaction by Canadians”, CBC Digital Archives (13 August 1978), online: <https://www.cbc.ca/archives/entry/the-worlds-first-test-tube-baby>.

[5] “Canada’s very own test tube baby”, CBC Digital Archives (10 February 1984), online: <https://www.cbc.ca/archives/entry/canadas-very-own-test-tube-baby>.

[6] Canada. Royal Commission on New Reproductive Technologies, Proceed with Care: Final Report of the Royal Commission on New Reproductive Technologies (Ottawa, Minister of Government Services Canada, 1993) at Preface xxvii, 115.

[7] Standing Committee on Health, Evidence Meeting, 37th Parl, 1st Sess, No 17 (29 May 2001) at 1125-55, 1240-45.

[8] Bill C-47, An Act Respecting Human Reproductive Technologies and Commercial Transactions Relating to Human Reproduction, 2nd Sess, 35th Parl, 1996 (first reading 14 June1996).

[9] Bill C-56, An Act respecting assisted human reproduction, 1st Sess, 37th Parl, 2002 (1st reading 9 May 2002); Bill C-13, An Act respecting assisted human reproduction and related research, 2nd Sess, 37th Parl, 2002-2003 (2nd reading 7 November 2003).

[10] Bill C-6, An Act respecting assisted human reproduction and related research, 3rd Sess, 37th Parl, 2004 (assented to 29 March 2004); Assisted Human Reproduction Act, SC 2004, c 2, ss 5-6.

[11] Reference re Assisted Human Reproduction Act, 2010 SCC 61, [2010] 3 SCR 457.

[12] See e.g. Susan Scutti, “At least 8 million IVF babies born in 40 years since historic first” (3 July 2018), online: CNN < .

[13] See e.g. Health Canada, Consultation on proposed assisted human reproduction regulations (Ottawa, Health Canada), online:<https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/programs/consultation-assisted-human-reproduction-regulations.html> (Date modified: 30 November 2018).

Related News

A collage of five headshots, the 2025–26 Vector Scholars, arranged in a 3x3 grid, with alternating colored squares in blue, dark blue, light blue, purple, green, and yellow filling the empty spaces; the individuals have varied hairstyles and clothing.

Advancing the Future of Health Through AI: IHPME Students Recognized with 2025–26 Vector Scholarships

May 29, 2025

Awards / Students

Read More
A digitally altered photo of three people standing side by side with faces obscured by gray rectangles; the background is a blurred, blue-tinted urban scene with colorful bars in orange, green, and purple in the corners.

IHPME-Affiliated Team Looped Advances in AI Competition

May 27, 2025

Faculty / Research / Students

Read More
A collage of images from the 21st Annual Research and Impact Day. The images include various scenes such as people receiving awards, attendees engaging in discussions, a keynote speaker presenting, and a display table with informational materials.

Bridging Research and Reality: 21st Annual Research and Impact Day Highlights Innovation and Collaboration

May 12, 2025

Faculty / Research / Students

Read More
A group of people are posing for a photo in a classroom. They are standing and kneeling in front of a large white projection screen. The room has wooden paneling on the walls and several desks with chairs arranged in rows. Some individuals are wearing masks, and various casual outfits can be seen.

Innovation in Action: Highlights from the 6th Health Systems AI Hackathon

April 30, 2025

Faculty / Research / Students

Read More
Portrait of Dr. Andrew Boozary, man with dark curly hair wearing a stethoscope around his neck and a black blazer with a red pin. He is standing in front of a whiteboard with pink writing."

Integrating Housing and Health: Dr. Andrew Boozary’s Vision for a More Equitable Toronto

April 25, 2025

Faculty

Read More
Alt text: A close-up portrait of a man with short, dark brown hair, slight stubble, and light skin. He is wearing a light blue collared shirt and has a confident, subtle smile. His eyes are looking directly at the camera. The background is a plain, off-white wall with soft lighting creating a gentle shadow on the left side of his face. Colourful accent blocks are seen in the top left and bottom right corners.

IHPME Student Elected to U of T’s Governing Council

March 31, 2025

Students

Read More

Sign up for IHPME Connect.

Keep up to date with IHPME’s News & Research, Events & Program, Recognition, e-newsletter.

Subscribe to Connect Newsletter

Get in Contact


Communications

Marielle Boutin
Email Address: ihpme.communications@​utoronto.ca

Manages all IHPME-wide communications and marketing initiatives, including events and announcements.